Thursday, February 13, 2014

The Presbyterian Church (U.S.A.) refuses to criticize Zionism Unsettled


The Presbyterian News Service has posted an item from The Presbyterian Church (U.S.A.) about the booklet, Zionism Unsettled, written and published by the Israel/Palestine Mission Network (IPMN). In the article, “Presbyterian Church (U.S.A.) remains committed to peace for Israelis and Palestinians,” the PC (U.S.A.), supposedly, absolved themselves from any guilt by claiming that that they had nothing to do with its writing or its publication. And they also pleaded innocence from behind the cover of the diversity of the denomination. They write: 

Presbyterian Church (U.S.A.) policy calls for a negotiated settlement between Israel and Palestine and the right for each to exist within secure and recognized borders. The church has condemned acts of violence on both sides of the conflict, as well as the illegal occupation of Palestinian land by Israeli settlements. Our church has categorically condemned anti-Semitism in all its forms, including the refusal to acknowledge the legal existence of the State of Israel. At the same time, we believe that condemnation of injustices perpetrated in the name of the State of Israel, including the violation of human rights, does not constitute anti-Semitism.

In 2004, the General Assembly of the Presbyterian Church (U.S.A.) formed the Israel Palestine Mission Network (IPMN) to help move the church toward the goal of a just peace in Israel/Palestine. The independent group — which speaks to the church and not for the church — recently published a study guide, Zionism Unsettled: A Congregational Study. The guide is intended to prompt discussion on the ever-changing and tumultuous issue of Israel-Palestine. The IPMN booklet was neither paid for nor published by the Presbyterian Church (U.S.A.).

There is more in the item. Linda Valentine, executive director of the Presbyterian Mission Agency, is quoted in part of the article. It is unclear if the above quote from the article is her’ or even the name or names of those who authored the article. It was undoubtedly a committee of people. At the beginning, in a box, it asks that the reader, if they want more information, to contact Kathy Francis, Communications Director, at 502-569-5194.

It does not matter that the PC (U.S.A.) has neither written nor published the booklet, Zionism Unsettled, they sell the booklet, and the IPMN is a part of their Mission Agency. It will be the members of IPMN and those they work with who will fill up the committee meeting room for Middle East issues and have full right to speak to the commissioners at the 221 General Assembly in June. There will not be another group in the PC (U.S.A.) who has that right. They not only speak to the denomination, they have power in the denomination to guide commissioners the direction they wish them to vote.

If leadership in the denomination, such as Linda Valentine, Stated Clerk Gradye Parsons, or Reverend Neal D. Presa, Moderator of the 220th General Assembly would speak out against such statements in the booklet as “Zionism is by nature a system of discrimination and exclusion,” the Jewish community and concerned Presbyterians could begin to breathe a sigh of relief.

There could at least be, once again, dialogue. But it is probable that that door has been closed.  As Rabbi Yitzchok Adlerstein has stated, “Such attacks describing our core belief as 'rooted' in 'intolerable human rights abuses' reveals there is nothing left to talk about with such religious bigots. Jews will now regard PCUSA as a hostile church.” And Presbyterian Pastor, Chris Leighton, writes in an Open Letter to the Presbyterian Church, for the Institute for Christian and Jewish Studies, “To suggest that the Jewish yearning for their own homeland—a yearning that we Presbyterians have supported for numerous other nations—is somehow theologically and morally abhorrent is to deny Jews their own identity as a people. The word for that is “anti-Semitism,” and that is, along with racism, sexism, homophobia, and all the other ills our Church condemns, a sin.”

I wrote a comment under the article, they have not published it. I await the day my denomination will have the courage and sense of righteousness it takes to stand against such evils as anti-Semitism.

Wednesday, February 12, 2014

Zionism Unsettled, Press TV of Iran & the Presbyterian Church (U.S.A.)


Yesterday I wrote about David Duke, the past Grand Wizard of the Ku Klux Klan, endorsing the Israel/Palestine Mission Network’s booklet Zionism Unsettled. Now Press TV is giving it an endorsement.  Press TV is one of the official media outlets for the  Islamic Republic of Iran.
Like other media outlets, they use press people in various countries to publish their news. Press TV uses Veterans Today for their United States News. Veterans Today is the site I have written so many postings about because of their extreme anti-Semitism. The Southern Poverty Law Center’s Hate Watch stated that they had entered the neo-Nazi realm because of their accusations about Israel and the Newtown murders. This is how Hate Watch put it:

 VT seemed to be trying to outdo itself when its financial editor Mike Harris, who also sits on VT’s editorial board, went on Iranian government-backed Press TV to claim that the recent murders of 20 small children and six adults at Sandy Hook Elementary school was carried out by Israeli death squads.

Press TV’s endorsement can be found here, “Zionism destroying lives of Palestinians, Jews: IPMN.” In the article they state, “The study guide, dubbed Zionism Unsettled, also argues that most Jews reject Zionism and choose to live outside the Israeli-occupied Palestinian lands, depicting Jewish life inside the Islamic Republic of Iran as “alive and well.”

The Jewish community that lives within Iran is often used by Iran to prove that Jews reject Zionism as well as Israel. But initially that rejection by some ultra-religious Jews had to do with their views that there would be no homeland until the Messiah came. Pushing aside the religious thinking, it is politicized and used as a caricature of Jews outside of Israel by both the Israel/Palestine Mission Network and the Republic of Iran.

But the Jewish state of Israel is like a lynch pin for many of those Jews who live in other places. It is that which undergirds the Jewish people of many lands and many persecutions. As Walter Laqueur points out in his seminal work, A History of Zionism: From the French Revolution to the Establishment of the State of Israel:

A survey of the origins of Zionism must take as its starting point the central place of Zion in the thoughts, the prayers, and the dreams of the Jews in their dispersion. The blessing ‘Next year in Jerusalem ‘ is part of the Jewish ritual and many generations of practicing Jews have turned towards the East when saying the Shemone Essre, the central prayer in the Jewish Liturgy.

It does not matter that the Jewish people make other countries their home, the Jewish State of Israel is the answer to two-thousand years of prayer. Marina Benjamin, author of The Last Days in Babylon, while rightly complaining of the way the Iraqian Jewish immigrants to Israel were at first treated, nontheless states:

Jewish people will often remark that only in Israel does their feeling of Jewishness disappear, because only in Israel, where being Jewish is the pervasive norm is it inconsequential. Having visited Israel several times, I can vouch for having experienced this strange unburdening.

On the Facebook page of the Presbyterian Church (U.S.A.) I argued about this horrible booklet Zionism Unsettled. This is the answer I got from whoever oversees the site and whose title is “Presbyterian Church (U.S.A.)

Presbyterian Church (U.S.A.) The Israel/Palestine Mission Network authored the booklet, and the network was created following a directive from the General Assembly in 2004 to move us toward the goal of a just peace in Israel/Palestine. The booklet is not a publication of the PC(USA). The network speaks to the church, not for the church.

That is not a good answer. The leadership in the PC (U.S.A.) is in some measure liable for their own organizations. If the IPMN, as an organization, decided to physically beat up those they considered their enemies, and they have done that emotionally, the PC (U.S.A.) would be liable for the physical damage done to the enemies—they are PC (USA) after all. But there is something more, and far more important. As a Christian organization the PC (U.S.A.) is liable for the wellbeing of others. Spiritually, they are called to justice and righteousness. Lying about, vilifying and slandering their neighbors is unscriptural, and as long as the leadership of the PC (U.S.A.) fails to speak up about Zionism Unsettled, they are involved in sin.
Picture of Jewish holiday Shavuot . Taken from Wikipedia & Jewish Free Image Collection Project. By Amos Gil.

Tuesday, February 11, 2014

Zionism Unsettled, David Duke & the Presbyterian Church (U.S.A.)


It seems that David Duke, past Grand Wizard of the Ku Klux Klan, really likes the Presbyterian Church (U.S.A.) and in particular Rev. Clifton Kirkpatrick, past stated clerk of the PC (U.S.A)’s General Assembly. But then he is mistaken, thinking that Kirkpatrick is the author of Zionism Unsettled. Duke undoubtedly read Kirkpatrick’s endorsement of the booklet:

I encourage pastors and congregations to take advantage of this new publication. Zionism Unsettled provides a valuable opportunity to explore the political ideology of Zionism. Our congregations need to understand not only the humanitarian crisis or the specific policies involved in the Israeli-Palestinian conflict but also to examine the basic framework that lies behind these policies and crises.

Duke likes Israel/Palestine Mission Network’s Zionism Unsettled because it uses a word he says he coined. It is included in his introduction which begins with this:

In a major breakthrough in the worldwide struggle against Zionist extremism, the largest Presbyterian church in the United States, the PC(USA), has issued a formal statement calling Zionism “Jewish Supremacism” — a term first coined and made popular by Dr. David Duke.

I have searched the booklet and cannot find that exact term although Zionism Unsettled is peppered with phrases that fit the idea of Zionism as “Jewish Supremacism.” There are references over and over to Jewish and/or Zionist exceptionalism as the dark side. There is an insistence that Israel cannot be a Jewish State and be a democracy. There are references  to the supposed ethnic cleansing by Zionists. There is the quote that “Zionism is by nature a system of discrimination and exclusion.”

And there is this, ""However, because equal rights for all would compromise the concept of a Jewish state, a dual legal system had to be created to ensure Jewish supremacy." on page 53.
Duke’s admiration for the booklet includes other statements from Zionism Unsettled:

It blames the expulsion of Jews from Arab lands as “blowback” from the “perceived injustice of the enforced partition of Palestine, the creation of a Jewish state, the ethnic cleansing of Palestinians in 1947-48, and the Sinai War of 1956.”
It accuses Israel of intentionally depopulating Palestinian villages in 1948, a process that continues to this day.
“Now, 65 years later, the Zionist quest for demographic control of the land in still underway – not only in the occupied territories, but within Israel itself. State planners pursue the goal of ensuring a ‘contiguous Jewish presence’ in every area within Israel.”
Morever [sic], the book argues, Israel is entirely uninterested in peace, and does not negotiate in good faith. “It is hard to find any evidence,” the authors write, “that recent Israeli governments have any intention of negotiating a just peace with Palestinians.”

That David Duke would claim agreement with the IPMN’s publication Zionism Unsettled should cause those in leadership of the Presbyterian Church (U.S.A.) to tremble because they are potentially in league with one of the leading bigots and anti-Semites of contemporary America.

When one writes a racist or an anti-Semitic book they should expect those who are racist and anti-Semitic to agree with them. In fact, James Wall, who writes and edits for Veterans News Now and is linked to Veterans Today, a vile anti-Semitic site which sometimes uses David Duke, has written an endorsement for them, calling Zionism Unsettled a "well timed and important study guide.*

Evil breeds deeper evil. 

* The endorsement is posted on their site-


Picture from Wikipedia

Saturday, February 8, 2014

IPMN, agreeing with those who harass Jewish women ...


The Israel/Palestine Mission Network of the Presbyterian Church (U.S.A.) is evidently giving lessons on how to harass and hate people. Using other’s tweets they have linked to an extremely hateful article about the controversy between the Boycott Divestment Sanctions  movement and Scarlett Johansson’s endorsement of SodaStream, a company that makes home soda making machines.
One of their plants is on the outskirts of an Israeli settlement. At least five-hundred Palestinians work there, alongside Israeli workers.* They make better wages then most in the Palestinian territories and are treated equally well. But the BDS movement is boycotting them and is now harassing Johansson because she was in a Super Bowl commercial lauding their product.

The article, “Scarlett Johansson controversy shows Hollywood’s fading Zionism,” written by Max Blumenthal, uses stereotyping to make points, while at the same time, referring to liberals who are pro-Israel as PEP (Progressives except for Palestine).  [1]Blumenthal’s disrespect for women in general, and Jewish women in particular is shameful. Of Barbra Streisand he writes:

  Of all the stars on stage that night, it was the proudly Jewish singer and actress Barbra Streisand who stole the show. The curly-haired Streisand belted out schlock anthems like Tomorrow and Happy Days Are Here Again to an enchanted crowd, before the former Israeli prime minister Golda Meir appeared on a gigantic television screen above the stage to greet her.
Curly-haired and schlock songs—what are the members of IPMN thinking linking to this piece. Blumenthal goes on:

Starting with her donation to the Emergency Committee for Israel during the 1967 war, Streisand’s unabashed Zionism propelled her career.
In other words Streisand made it big, not because of her talent, but because she was a Zionist. (Wasn't there an earlier time in history, the 1930s, when people of questionable character, the Nazis, insisted that the Jews controlled Hollywood and all of the United States media?)
In another part of the article, Blumenthal’s writes:

These days, celebrities who shill for Israel can expect to be relentlessly harried and forced to declare where they stand on Israel’s ongoing dispossession of Palestinians.

For those who have attached themselves to humanitarian do-gooder causes, the potential for PR damage is considerable — certainly enough to give them second thoughts. As the price tag on pro-Israel activity rises, some performers are quietly opting out of attractive deals before the controversy shatters their image.

But others like Scarlett Johansson, the comely blonde starlet described by Woody Allen as “sexually overwhelming” were not willing to let apartheid get in the way of a sizeable profit.
Woody Allen’s description of Johansson is totally out of place—but yes—it seems that Blumenthal will continue to harry and harass. He is shameless and so is the IPMN of the PC (U.S.A.).

I predict that since IPMN has published its hateful Zionism Unsettled they will sink deeper and deeper into the dark world of bigotry and hate. Once sin overcomes an individual or an organization it becomes easier to commit offenses.

To clarify: I don’t usually write postings defending movie stars simply because too many times I don’t agree with their lifestyles, but as a Christian I understand that everyone is created in the image of God. In our denomination, the Presbyterian Church (U.S.A.), we are certainly expected to respect that image in everyone. We particularly lift up women and their rights. The IPMN has for a long time used other’s links to harass Scarlett Johansson. Their meanness is unacceptable. The article I am complaining about attacks persons in a way that is far deeper than attacking their actions. Whether one agrees with Scarlett Johansson or not, she should be treated as one who bears the image of God. And there isn’t any reason at all for Barbra Streisand to be attacked. Hopefully it is not a sin to be Jewish and/or a Zionist.

 
* An excellent article on the plant and workers in Mishor Adumim industrial park, is "Palestinian workers praise SodaStream - and Scarlett Johansson."



[1]   Blumenthal and IPMN promote each other’s work.  

Thursday, February 6, 2014

Zionism Unsettled: Good links that stand for righteousness and truth-Update


I recently posted a review of the Israel/Palestine Mission Network’s new publication Zionism Unsettled. Now, while radical sites and groups are busy pushing the IPNM’s publication, several well-known and excellent organizations, both Presbyterian and Jewish, have published reviews and statements about the publication which detail Zionism Unsettled’s many problems.
Presbyterians for Middle East Peace published a Press Release, “A Call for Justice and Tolerance in Israel and Palestine.”  The second paragraph explains their basic concern:

Recently the PC (USA) on-line “church store” began distributing a “congregational study guide” of a forthcoming publication titled “Zionism Unsettled.” The “study guide” was compiled by the Israel-Palestine Mission Network (IPMN), an advocacy group describing itself as an organization that “speaks to the Church, not for the Church.”  We take no issue with this group, or anyone else, expressing their opinions and exercising their rights of free speech.  Our concern, however, is that this material will be seen and is already being seen by much of the outside world as an official document of the Presbyterian Church (USA)  As a case in point, a recent article about this material appeared on the website Electronic Intifada entitled “Zionism is a ’false theology,’ says new Presbyterian study guide.”

And in fact, the vile anti-Semitic site Veterans News Now has also posted the same article with a different title: “Zionism Unsettled: New Presbyterian study guide Ends Silence about Zionism”
The Simon Wiesenthal Center has also put out a press release, Wiesenthal Center: US Presbyterians’ “Zionism Unsettled” -Theological Twin Of UN’s Infamous ‘Zionism is Racism’ Resolution.” Their protest cuts to the heart of the matter, with this publication the Israel/Palestine Mission Network has totally demonized Israel and the Jews. Quoting Rabbi Abraham Cooper the Press Release states:

“Zionism Unsettled is a hit-piece outside all norms of interfaith dialogue. It is a compendium of distortions, ignorance and outright lies – that tragically has emanated too often from elites within this church”

The Wiesenthal Center calls on Christians to stand against this awful publication:

It will take Christian voices to offer the antidote to the poison served up by other Christians. [i]And if this book reflects the feelings of the PCUSA, the Simon Wiesenthal Center will divest all contacts from this institution and call on other Jewish organizations to do them same.

Rabbi Yitzchok Adlerstein of the Center has put the problem squarely where it belongs:

Such attacks describing our core belief as ‘rooted’ in ‘intolerable human rights abuses’ reveals there is nothing left to talk about with such religious bigots.

The Press Release must be read by all PC (U.S.A.) members to understand the grievous place we all are in because of the IPMN.
The AJC Global Jewish Action also has an article, “AJC: Presbyterian Church (USA) Study Guide on Zionism Distorts History, Undermines Peace Process” In their article, they state:

This study guide, billed by the church as an educational resource, was produced by the Israel Palestine Mission Network (IPMN), one of the church’s educational arms. “It is a devastating distortion of Jewish and Israeli history, aimed at nothing less than eradicating the State of Israel,” said Rabbi Noam Marans, AJC’s Director of Intergroup and Interreligious Relations.

All Presbyterians, but especially those going as commissioners to the General Assembly of the Presbyterian Church (U.S.A.), this coming June, need to read these Press Releases and articles to understand that with the booklet Zionism Unsettled our denomination has reached a trembling point-a historical point—we will either become a vile anti-Semitic denomination or we will stand against a rising tide of universal bigotry and hate against the Jewish people.

Update: Another excellent and very informative statement on Zionism Unsettled has just been published by The Institute for Christian and Jewish Studies. Written by Reverend Chris Leighton, Executive Director of the Institute for Christian & Jewish Studies and a Presbyterian pastor, "An Open Letter to the Presbyterian Church," is extremely important. This is but one small quote from a letter filled with truth and compassion:

"To suggest that the Jewish yearning for their own homeland—a yearning that we Presbyterians have supported for numerous other nations—is somehow theologically and morally abhorrent is to deny Jews their own identity as a people. The word for that is “anti-Semitism,” and that is, along with racism, sexism, homophobia, and all the other ills our Church condemns, a sin."

 




[i] I don’t believe that those members of IPMN who allowed and agreed with this document’s statements that Jesus is not the complete revelation of God can be called Christians.

Wednesday, February 5, 2014

The Presbyterian News Service, Cuba, and religious freedom


The Presbyterian News Service has recently been concentrating on news from Cuba including the Presbyterian Reformed Church in Cuba and the “Evangelico Seminario Teologia (Evangelical Theological Seminary, or SET).” The latest article, “Real Family Values,” is about Nelson Davila, a pastor and teacher who has devised a program that will help young people to be good citizens in all areas of their lives. Davila teaches a class at SET called, “The Church and Citizen Formation.” However, talking about this to PNS, Davila made a statement that raised a question in my mind. As the author of the PNS article put It, while quoting Davila:

“We have many churches in Cuba that are just trying to be in the headlines,” Davila said, “but that is not the real gospel. The real gospel is humble and seeks to serve the least, to make them better human beings.

“We should not be seeking recognition,” he continued. “Our only purpose is to serve the Lord.”

Well, yes, but I find it amazing that in a communist country any church is attempting to 'be in the headlines.' So perhaps it has something to do with those who are trying to gain religious freedom in Cuba.

Two news reports about ministry in Cuba, one from Christianity Today's Gleamings and one from the Presbyterian News Service, appeared on the same day. Together they are an image of theological contradiction. The CT one is about Lleonart Barroso, a Baptist pastor in Cuba, “Cuba Case Study: Bonhoeffer-Inspired Pastor Arrested after Blogs, Tweets and D.C. Trip.” Barroso is under house arrest because, as Gleamings writer, Melissa Kimiadi put it, he visited the “Congressional Caucus on Religious Freedom” and delivered a 30-point challenge to his Communist government.” A news article at, “Christian Solidarity outlines much of the challenge concerning Cuba's communist government and religious freedom:
The declaration and questions outline the most pressing concerns raised by the group, including the government's continued refusal to extend official recognition to newer religious groups, the approval or denial of legal rights to registered groups based on perceived political support and cooperation, and the sweeping authority over religious organisations and activities held by the Office of Religious Affairs (ORA) of the Central Committee of the Cuban Communist Party. The group pointed to mass arrests during the visit of Pope Benedict XVI and new restrictions, including a decree that as of January 2014, churches and religious groups will no longer be able to hold individual bank accounts and existing accounts must be consolidated into one per denomination or organisation as proof that the government is not interested in true reforms that would protect freedom of religion or belief.
Barroso is a Christian activist advocating for religious freedom in Cuba. According to the author he is influenced by Bonhoeffer and the Confessing Churches of Nazi Germany.

The other news story on PNS, “A Long Strange Trip: God's Call Leads Theological Student From Dominican Republic to South Bronx to Cuba,” is about Manolo De Los Santos and his work and studies in Cuba. The piece is from the Presbyterian Mission Agency. At the end of the piece the author who is not named quotes Santos writing, “ Life in Cuba is very difficult, De Los Santos says — some of it brought on by the Cubans themselves but much of it imposed on them by the 60-year-old U.S. embargo of Cuba.”

The author quotes Santos' description of the state's provision for the people which seems to contradict the difficult life he says they live:
What impacts me every day is the witness of all the people, not just the Christians,” he said. “They don’t give a second thought to health care, education and personal security, which is fully provided in Cuba. I think about the South Bronx, where that is not the case at all, and I’m astounded and moved.
The article ends with Santos' hope for the future, “The witness of the Cuban people — not just the Christians — De Los Santos says,“is a witness that shows the world what could be. As Christians, we see Jesus as the new paradigm for humanity. Without replacing Jesus, Cuba is struggling for the same.”

Those are the two stories as one reads the articles, but there is more in other news outlets. Santos made his journey to Cuba via a group of activist. He evidently went with a group who were taking aid to Cuba via Mexico and also a message. On ACN (Cuban News Agency) in an article, dated July 16, 2013, “Peace Caravan Reaches Mexico via in Route to Cuba” the author names Santos as a coordination team member and writes:
The Caravan also brings messages from the American people against the US blockade imposed by Washington, as well as voices for the freedom of the Cuban Five, as the anti-terrorist fighters held in US jails are internationally known, said de los Santos.
 The article also tells of the actions of this caravan alongside other organizations. The author writes:
Manolo de los Santos announced a protest action in front of the US embassy in Mexico, which will send a message about the unity of the people in this continent against Washington's hostile policy against Cuba and humanity.

We are many, united in a single voice for Cuba and there we will join our friends from the Francisco Villa People's Front, the Mexico-Cuba Solidarity Movement, the Ecclesial Observatory and other social organizations, the community and ecumenical groups,” said de los Santos.
Remembering that the ACN is an official paper of Cuba one still wonders why “The Francisco Villa People's Front” can only be found, aside from Cuba Solidarity groups, listed as a terrorist group and then there is little information only references to an assassination in Mexico.

The Mexico-Cuba Solidarity Movement is a part of Cuba's Solidarity groups in many countries. They at the very least are socialist. The Ecclesial Observatory is a Catholic group which denies most social teaching of the Catholic Church. And certainly all of these groups are aligned with the Cuban government which is failing to give complete religious freedom to its people. Whether one agrees with the embargo the United States government has in place against Cuba it seems to me we should be allowed to hear, from our own denominational news outlet, the whole news.

What about religious freedom in Cuba? Does being a good citizen mean being passive in the face of tyranny and loss of freedom?

A beautiful movie, The Lost City, about Havana, Cuba, before the communist revolution and afterwards, shows both the totalitarianism before communism and the irrational totalitarianism afterwards. The main star who is Cuban, Andy Garcia, in an interview expresses how Czechoslovakia had their revolution and finally arrived at democracy, but Cuba is still waiting.





Saturday, February 1, 2014

The Presbyterian Church (U.S.A.) and my complaint ...

I just went out to my first day of a February garden. I needed the sunshine—needed to feel the softness of the wood sorrel as I pulled it away from tiny parsley and leek plants. I picked some very ripe lemons and a few snap peas. I brought them in and sat down here at my computer to complain—I’m not sure who I'm complaining to—God, The Presbyterian Church (U.S.A.), no one in particular.

It's just that I never thought for a moment that I would belong to an organization that would so badly attack the people who gave us our holy book, the Bible. Well, of course, it is God's book, his word, but he called and used the Jewish people to write the Hebrew part of our Holy Scriptures. And God used Jewish converts to our Lord Jesus Christ to write the New Testament.

Zionism, it has been a safety net for the Jewish people. It matters not whether it is cultural Zionism or political Zionism: it is the shell around the fruit of their culture and the work of their political groanings. I say groanings because like all new democracies they are still in the process of working out the process of liberty and equality. But to see my denomination stand behind a document, Zionism Unsettled, that calls Zionism, “a system of discrimination and exclusion,” is more than I can stand.

My denomination, the Presbyterian Church (U.S.A.), has allowed a Palestinian pastor who is suppose to be a Christian, but undoubtedly isn't, to write in one of our denominational booklets that Zionism's inspiration has been drawn “from those portions [of the Bible] that betray a narrow and exclusive concept of a tribal god.” Truly we have aligned with the German Christians of Nazi-times because this is what they believed and said. They do not care for God's word and they do not care for the Jewish people. They have insulted both. And I find myself weeping in places where I never intended to cry.

What does one do when they find themselves weeping in the middle of the aisle in, of all things, the grocery store. What does one do when they find themselves privately saying goodbye to a denomination they have been a part of for over twenty years. Oh, not goodbye in the sense of I won't be here anymore—but in the sense of, my heart is no longer here. My face is turned a different direction and it is hard to keep traveling back over the roads that have gone from rocky to granite.