Thursday, November 15, 2007

Presbyterians, Karl Marx, New Hampshire and the Zapatistas?


During the late summer I placed several posts on my blog entitled “Presbyterians Dancing with Karl Marx.” Just about a week ago I placed some correspondence on my blog between myself and Stephen Bartlett, Coordinator for Constituency Education, with Agricultural Missions Inc. an organization affiliated with several mainline Christian denominations including Presbyterian Women and Presbyterian Hunger Program.1

One of my points in the posts was that Agricultural Missions Inc. was too deeply affiliated with a new movement which includes both the World Social Forum and the United States Social Forum . Both of these movements are related and have their roots in extreme socialism and Marxism. I asked Mr. Bartlett some questions about statements he had made including his statements about the 2006 World Social Forum which was:


"How socialism is defined and envisioned today goes beyond rigid Marxist Leninist or even Maoist concepts, and seeks for its roots in indigenous cosmovision and collective governance practices, in a radically decentralized vision for a world in which, as the Zapatistas demand, all worlds fit."

All of Mr. Bartlett’s essay about that forum can be found here: [reflections from the AMI (Agricultural Missions, Inc) Agrarian Delegation to the World Social Forum, Jan 19-31, 2006].
As I stated in the last post, on this subject, my main interest is to now pull together some of the ideas sweeping through these grassroots socialist movements and look at them through the lens of history. Finally I want to look at the Church of Jesus Christ in relation to these groups and movements.

But first some observations about some of Mr. Bartlett’s thoughts which he was very gracious to share in the last post found here:
Presbyterians, Karl Marx, Cosmovision and Letters. I asked Michael Kruse of Kruse Kronicle, who writes a great deal on economics, if he would read the letter and the essay and comment. He has given permission for my use of material from his e-mail.2

The first comment I have is that in reading Mr. Bartlett’s letter I found his distinctions between capitalism and socialism a bit murky. It was hard to understand which was which, almost as though one was bleeding over into the other. I think the reader will find more clarification about capitalism by reading Michael Kruse’s definitions:

“What do we mean by capitalism? Here are some basic elements I would include:

* Privately owned business enterprises

* Relatively free markets

* Players in pursuit of endless win-win transactions

* Investment of wealth in productive activities

* Long-term future returns oriented

* Circumscribed in a strong juridical framework governing property rights and transactional justice”

Another problem I had was Bartlett’s push for what he calls 'Collective governance practices' and/or consensus decision making. He pointed to the Zapatista’s indigenous communities (a revolutionary group in Mexico) as one example and to the town hall meetings in New Hampshire as another example. The Zapatistas are attempting to forge their own territory with their own laws and economy within the country of Mexico; the people of New Hampshire are attempting to take part in the democratic practices of the United States by participating in local government. (Part of the murkiness I was referring to.)

In Kruse’s e-mail he complements Bartlett, “In some ways Bartlett is on the right track. Things need to be done through experimentation at the local level.” And here I agree. Bartlett is writing about farmers who make contracts with people in the city to buy their food directly from them. In reality the people have bought into the farm and are paying those who labor on the farm.

It is an exchange which is helpful to both sides. This is a popular practice in California where I live. But it is not socialism, it is instead localized capitalism. I can choose to buy from the farmer, buy from the farmer’s market, go to my favorite small grocery store or go to a supermarket. As for the favorite small grocery store, recently one of the butchers bought out the owner and is expanding the products selection including the wine section which was already exceptional. This is a picture of capitalism at its best and it has a lot to do with freedom.

Kruse continues, “But the aim should be for markets to emerge along with a just system of law and property rights. As wisdom from these experimentations is learned and multiplied, each nation should be able to emerge its own particular forms of economic freedom limited by certain other concerns just as they are limited in developed nations.”

But as far as such decisions about markets being made by collective governance practices Kruse has this to say:



“But the idea that a healthy national economy can be run by an expertocracy or consensus model of decision-making, is not only misguided, it will damn the population to poverty perpetually. Markets and genuine economic freedom are essential. The idea that collective economic decision making could even be possible comes from the communitarian wing of the Enlightenment/Modernist era, with its belief that sufficient reason applied by an expertocracy can lead us to a utopian common or social good. Marx was, of course, the poster boy for such
visions.”

There are other areas that are just touched on in both Bartlett’s letter and essay which I want to address using other material. One is the concept of cosmovision and indigenous peoples; here the problem of freedom of religion for the individual is emerging. Another issue is the changing world of socialism and Marxism. A postmodern debate is developing within socialism.

I also want to write about the conflicts arising because of the green movement which in its extreme forms is blending fascist socialism with leftist socialism. It is also of interest to know that there is a rising anti-Semitism in both extreme left and extreme right.

See Also: Presbyterians Dancing With Karl Marx! Part 1

Presbyterians Dancing With Karl Marx! Part 2

Presbyterians Dancing with Karl Marx Part 3

(1 )In answer to a question I asked Ms Ann Ferguson, Program Coordinator, of Presbyterian Women, she stated in an e-mail to me that none of the line items in the PW budget were included in the money given to AMI. Rather the money came from the offering taken at the Presbyterian Women’s Gathering in 2006. The Editors of Horizon’s magazine reported in their Sept/Oct 2006 edition, that, “The Gathering Offering, collected during Sunday morning’s plenary session, totaled $54, 363. 61. This money will support women farmers, rangers and farm workers thanks to two organizations—Agricultural Missions, Inc. and Rural Coalition.” They go on to explain that it will also go to the Widening the Circle Fund. (27)

The AMI front page of their web site has this information: Rural Women's Gathering planned for Nov 1-5, 2007 in Mexico City and Oaxtepec, Mexico. 25 women from partner organizations of both Agricultural Missions and Rural Coalition, from the U.S., Mexico, Central America and the Caribbean will gather to envision the future of rural community and economic life, to plan for future consciousness raising and to help create educational materials for people of faith. The planning process includes AMI board members Lorette Picciano, Marta Benavides, Shirley Sherrod, Shelly Vendiola and Sherry Flyr. AMI staff Stephen Bartlett and Mozzie Johnson have been accompanying this planning process. This has been made possible through the generous support of Presbyterian Women. (Bold Mine)

(2 )Michael Kruse is at this time doing a series on Christian “Economic Fallacies.” He has finished two: Economic Fallacies: "Work is Instrumental" and Economic Fallacies: "Biblical Redistribution". They are both very important reading for Christians and I am sure the rest of them will clarify errors about economic thinking from a Christian point of view.



Wednesday, November 14, 2007

Good News From Afar: My Missionary Friends in Thailand


On Oct. the 17th I wrote about my missionary friends in Thailand, Good News From Afar . I wrote that I would start posting their newsletters but "because of some of the places they travel and because of the wonderful Christians they minister to, who live in suffering places, I cannot post their names. But this will give others a chance to read the wonderful stories they send and to pray for another part of the Church."

Here is the second posting.

Ministry to Children

These past months, I have been joining another missionary and some of her Thai workers in a ministry to the children’s cancer ward at the University Hospital here in ChiangMai. Hospital conditions are very crowded with 12 to 15 patients per room, plus one or both of their parents who are there to watch after them. Family members are expected to be the main caregivers, and they spend day and night with their children, even sleeping on straw mats beside or under the child’s bed. It is incredibly tiring and stressful for them. The children are at the hospital to receive IV chemotherapy, so they are often feeling ill from the side effects of the treatment. The objective of our visits is to provide a much needed diversion from the daily stress and boredom of being in the hospital situation..

Our time usually involves a song, a story or puppet show and a small handicraft that the children can do. The presentation of Christianity has to be a bit low key, but there are opportunities to share more openly. Christmas is a time when it is acceptable to give a Christian presentation. We actually have greater freedom here than we would in similar situations back home. Sometimes there is opportunity to pray with the parents or patients if the situation allows. This last week I met a 12 year old girl who attends a church in a small town about five hours away, where we worked years ago. I was able to pray with her, which was an encouragement, since she is at the hospital with her unbelieving father. Her mother who is a Christian had to remain at home to watch over the younger siblings.


Your heart certainly goes out to these youngsters and their families. It makes you more thankful for the life and health that we enjoy, and remember not to take it for granted. If Jesus were to come to ChiangMai, I think that we would see him in the hospital halls.

Please pray for continued open doors. The hospital staff has mentioned that they appreciate our efforts. Pray that we will be sensitive to each individual, and speak words that bring encouragement and life.

Sunday, November 11, 2007

A Side-Trip Into Barmen and the One Word of God


Today in my church we had a sermon concerned with The Theological Declaration of Barmen as well as a Sunday school class on the same subject. As a refresher on this Declaration, last night, I got out one of my favorite books, The Church’s Confession Under Hitler by Arthur C. Cochrane. The Office of the General Assembly actually used this book's copy of The Barmen Declaration when it was printed in the PCUSA’s Book of Confessions.

Also included in this book is “An Address on the Theological Declaration Concerning the Present Situation in the German Evangelical Church.” This was an address given to the delegates of Barmen by Pastor Hans Asmussen. It is a point by point explanation of Barmen by a pastor who was deeply involved in the Confessing Church’s actions.

This afternoon, when I once again had my attention drawn to a blog with postings propounding unbiblical caricatures of the Christian faith as well as continued mocking of Christians and Jesus Christ I couldn’t help thinking of some of the words of both Asmussen and the Theological Declaration of Barmen.

Before I write about those words, I will give an example of the abuse heaped on believers and Jesus Christ alike using one posting where this particular Presbyterian Pastor insists that biblical Christianity is passé. In the posting “
How Literalist Christianity Often Appears to Those Who Are Not Christian,” the pastor continues to push progressive theology which for him includes the denial of Jesus as God as well as the denial of the bodily resurrection of believers. In the comments on that posting he further denies the validity of orthodox faith with his statement:

That point is simply this: popular (literalist, fundamentalist, whatever)
Christianity is absurd. To equate the main dogmas of Christianity with any kind of reality save mythical and symbolic is incredible. Steve's definition simply removes the pious veneer. [For Steve’s definition see posting]
Is the Apostle's Creed credible on any level except myth? (Bold mine) [See note at end of my post]

Pastor Asmussen refers to the section of Barmen that speaks of a particular false doctrine the Confessing Churches rejected, in this case, “as though the Church could and would have to acknowledge as a source of its proclamation, apart from and besides this one Word of God, still other events and powers, figures and truths as God’s revelation.” (8.12 in Book of Confessions)

Asmussen explains:

For the sake of our Lord Jesus Christ we may not become weary of stressing repeatedly that it is false doctrine when other authorities are set up for the Church beside the incarnate Word in Christ and the Word proclaimed in him. That is what is happening today. … For it is only a relative difference whether beside Holy Scripture in the Church historical events or reason, culture, aesthetic feelings, progress, or other powers and figures are said to be binding claims upon the Church. All these factors cannot limit the proclamation of Christ, nor can they take a place beside Christ as subjects of proclamation. In proclamation they can have no other place than that of various marks of the one, basically unchanged world, which can find redemption in Christ and only in Christ. (254-55)

To put it more succinctly, historical events, reason, culture, aesthetic feelings, and yes even progress including progressive theology are placed under sin and in need of redemption in Jesus Christ.

Another important point in Asmussen’s sermon is that although the Church in Germany still held the Confessions and had a constitution, the unity of the Church in Germany was in peril because of the actions of the Church administration and the “German Christians.” He states, “It is not a case of occasional mistakes by individuals that one finds in administrative matters and could thus be removed. On the contrary, it is a question of a false doctrine all along the line and of a conduct that not only occasionally but systematically and comprehensively opposes the gospel, the Confessions presently in force, and the constitution of the German Evangelical Church.”

The idea here is that a Church, having orthodox confessions and constitution, and more importantly the Holy Scriptures, can still, because of church politics and administrational maneuvering, pursue false doctrine which causes disunity in the Church. Lack of discipline is often administrational maneuvering.

"I am the way, and the truth, and the life: no one comes to the Father, but by me." (John 14:6) "Truly, Truly, I say to you, he who does not enter the sheepfold by the door but climbs in by another way that man is a thief and a robber. ... I am the door; if anyone enters by me, he will be saved." (John 10:1, 9.) (8.10) Book of Confessions

Note: "There have been many complaints and murmurings over this formula [The Apostles' Creed] and probably, sooner or later in your studies, you will come up against men of letters and even teachers, who also do the same and think it dreadful that this matter should be reduced to this formula. . . This inveighing against so-called 'orthodoxy' is just a 'wolf's snarl', which an educated man should have nothing to do with."
Karl Barth
Dogmatics in Outline



Thursday, November 8, 2007

Presbyterians, Karl Marx, Cosmovision and Letters


This last summer I began a series of articles entitled "Presbyterians Dancing With Karl Marx!” The focus of the articles was several national and international groups and movements that various organizations in the PCUSA are affiliated with. My concern was Christian endorsement of ideologies that are unacceptable if Jesus Christ is Lord.

Because I erred in attributing a quote to the wrong person, I sent a letter to the person I was informed actually made the statement. I did this because I wanted to be certain that he had made the statement, but also because I wished to ask him about another paper and statement he wrote. Stephen Bartlett, Coordinator for Constituency Education, Agricultural Missions, wrote me back a gracious and interesting letter. (I wish, before hand, to commend him for his work with community gardens and children.)

Because I plan to write some more on this subject I am placing my letter to Mr. Bartlett and his response in this posting. His letter is long and I will later have a great deal I want to write so the posting of both of our letters will be the first part of this round of postings.

But first I want to stress that my next round of articles on this particular subject will deal with religious and political movements of the late nineteenth and first half of the twentieth century, as well as their renewed images in our contemporary world. I will be using the first part of
Presbyterians Dancing With Karl Marx! Part 2 as my starting point. My concern is how the Church can be faithful to her Lord in the midst of a fragmenting world in flux. I intend to uphold the Lordship of Christ and His redeeming life and death.

Here are the letters:

Dear Mr. Bartlett,

I have written an article entitled "Presbyterians Dancing with Karl Marx." I posted it in three parts and placed it on my blog, "
Naming His Grace." As you can see from this mornings posting I attributed a quote I believe you made to Ms. Sherry Flyr.

I thought I should be much more careful and ask if this is your quote? Are you the author of this statement concerning the USSF's classes on the Agricultural Missions' web site "Katrina, the War, Gender and the struggle against
Homophobic Patriarchical Violent Capitalism, Immigration Rights, Worker Justice and Indigenous Peoples and their Prophetic Struggles and Cosmovision."

I also decided that I should ask why you referred to capitalism as homophobic Patriarchical and violent? Beyond that I also note that in your report from the 2006 World Social Forum, [reflections from the AMI (Agricultural Missions, Inc) Agrarian Delegation to the World Social Forum, Jan 19-31, 2006],
you state, "How socialism is defined and envisioned today goes beyond rigid Marxist Leninist or even Maoist concepts, and seeks for its roots in indigenous cosmovision and collective governance practices, in a radically decentralized vision for a world in which, as the Zapatistas demand, all worlds fit." Could you please explain what that actually means? For instance, does going beyond rigid Marxist Leninist still include Marxism? What exactly is cosmovision? What are collective governance practices?

Thank you for taking the time to read this e-mail and respond.
Sincerely,
Viola Larson



“Dear Ms Viola Larson,
Warm greetings in Christ from Louisville, Kentucky! I am going to respond to your questions, but I would request that if you publish my reply to your email on your blog, that you do so in its entirety, and not in bits and pieces. Concepts like cosmovision and collective governance practices are not familiar to everyone. A shared understanding of what is meant by them is important to any serious dialog about emerging political and economic philosophies. Thank you in advance for that consideration.

Yes, the article you cited in your blog was from an article I wrote for our Netline publication, a publication of Agricultural Missions, Inc (AMI) with whom I have been working for nearly eight years. You may have been confused by a listing of workshop leaders that said Yours truly (referring to me, not Sherry), Sherry Flyr, Luckner Millien... If you click over to the Netline Publication from the homepage (not from the USSF 'more' link), you can see the same article, with my name prominently listed as the author.

The plenary sessions I was referring to at the US Social Forum were presented as they were entitled in the Forum itself. The choice of plenary themes would have been the decision of a large and diverse council responsible for organizing the forum plenaries and representing various organizations and social movements. In the article you quoted, I did not infer or make any judgment on their content but merely reported their overarching themes. But if you would like to have a more in-depth correspondence on the concepts and themes in question, that is possible. To explain these themes adequately would require a great many pages. I am still prayerfully learning about them myself, in my calling as a disciple of Christ, as a farmer, urban agriculturalist, teacher of gardening to children and advocate for peace and social justice. I am a member of Crescent Hill Presbyterian Church in Louisville, Kentucky, where I coordinate a community garden, now in its 11th year and 6th year of summer gardening camps for children of diverse backgrounds.

I will try to define cosmovision for you. Cosmovision refers to an overarching worldview, or a cosmology or vision of the cosmos. It is most often referring to those beliefs about reality held by a great many Indigenous Peoples around the world, and in particular in the Americas (including North, South, Central America and the Caribbean). It expresses a worldview deeply rooted in the natural world.

Since in my work with Agricultural Missions (founded in 1930) it is my job to learn about and to accompany and support the efforts of people of the land, including indigenous people, we are respectful of religious or cosmovision beliefs different from our own Christian beliefs. Call it a humble and loving attitude of ecumenicity and interfaith dialog and mutual respect. It is our experience that indigenous cosmovision and sustainable and reverent practices of land usage are of great value to humanity, particularly in these times of environmental crisis. It is also the case that many indigenous peoples, even those who may not be Christian, nevertheless show high respect to the teachings and life of Jesus. In Jesus they often see a great Healer of divine inspiration.

To respond to your question about the discussion of the new concept of 'socialism' developing in Latin America, Europe, Africa and Asia, which I mentioned in another article you cited, you may again infer that I am describing some aspects of the debate going on among those most impacted by the negative effects of neoliberal globalization, in various countries and regions. You may be aware that Christians too have been debating to what degree unregulated capitalism, based as it is on the unbridled profit motive or self-interest, reflects the Sermon on the Mount or not. Again, I am describing the debate as it is developing and not taking one position or another.

Karl Marx, like Adam Smith, Jeremy Bentham, John Maynard Keynes, Galbraith, etc... was a philosopher and an economist, a highly influential one in his day, and the concepts and analyses he contributed have become part and parcel of modern Western thought, whether you are from the Chicago School or are Neo-Keynesian. It is worth noting too that just as Marxism may take different forms, so does capitalism. So it is hard to define exactly what may be meant by the moniker 'Marxism.' Some forms of socialism have fallen down for a variety of reasons and some of them were characterized as rigid, doctrinaire, bureaucratic, overly-centralized, party-bound, etc... Going beyond those forms of so-called socialist societies was what I was referring to, in the general debate at that social forum. For example, today there are welfare state countries in Europe who see their origins in Marxist thought, because of their generous safety nets providing health care and education for all, for free or very inexpensively. One commonly held idea of what 'socialism' means is where the economy is organized around the benefits that can accrue to a society and its members. That is, socialism is often thought to be any economy where social good takes priority over the capitalistic values of wealth accumulation and concentration. As I mentioned before, the life and words of Jesus are often difficult to reconcile with an economy that may enrich some and impoverish others, or lay waste to the environment on a global scale. Hence the urgent search for alternative models for organizing society. Here in Louisville, for example, as part of the work of the Community Farm Alliance, a farmer-led organization seeking the betterment for local farmers and local consumers of food, we are creating what is being called a 'solidarity economy' whereby people buy their foods from local farmers directly, even if this may be less convenient or require more cooking. In this way, family farmers of our region can survive economically and society as a whole benefits. In fact, we are now finding ways for local farmers to get food directly into the hands of the lowest income people in impoverished neighborhoods, so that those least able to get fresh and healthy produce may do so, and creating a link of solidarity between urban dwellers and regional farmers. One could call this a form of capitalism or a form of socialism, according to one's use of those terms. We call it a solidarity economy, within a capitalist economy.

'Collective governance practices' refers to decision-making procedures and norms of a community, social sector, social movement, organization, company, country or international body or forum that do not rely exclusively upon what we call representative democratic procedures and Roberts Rules/Parliamentary Procedure, but rather on horizontal inclusive consultation, consensus building, and social accountability norms. It is thought, for example, that agrarian or hunter gatherer societies typically practiced and still do practice collective governance, as do towns in Vermont where townhall meetings are held to hash out decisions for the community, and everyone has a voice. The Zapatista indigenous communities to whom I referred utilize collective governance practices, which is why their decision-making process is slow and tedious. However, such thorough consultations and town meetings have the advantage that once a decision is taken, everyone stands behind that decision and it can be implemented at once by nearly everyone involved. The degree to which a society is democratic (reflecting the opinion of the majority, or involving wide participation in decision making processes) is not only a concept within capitalist societies (voting, performing civic duties, paying taxes), but also within so-called socialist societies or, ideally, non-hierarchical societies, where community councils and other consultative bodies allow members of society to participate in decision-making. In general such democratic procedures are often referred to as Participatory Democracy. That, in essence, was what I meant by my use of the term: Collective Governance Practices. Think of a town hall meeting in New Hampshire! And extrapolate.

I hope this helps clarify the concepts you referred to.

peace in Christ,

Stephen Bartlett
Coordinator for Constituency Education
Agricultural Missions, Inc. (AMI)
-----


Wednesday, November 7, 2007

Pastor Bob Campbell's Thoughts on FOG.

Pastor Bob Campbell, of Tully Memorial Presbyterian in Sharon Hill, PA, has posted, on his blog, some questions and comments he is asking about both the FOG report, COMMENTS AND QUESTIONS CONCERNING THE NEW FORM OF GOVERNMENT , and the Foundation of Presbyterian Polity report, COMMENTS ON THE FOUNDATIONS OF PRESBYTERIAN POLITY .

I think Bob has some well thought out questions and comments and so I have linked to them and posted some of them here.

Some comments and questions on the former are:

"G-1.0101: “All the gifts of the gospel necessary to being the church are present to the congregation.” This sentence would be clearer if it said . . . present in the congregation.

Old G-5.0103 new G-1.0302: I think the deletion of this: “No persons shall be denied membership because of race, ethnic origin, worldly condition” is a mistake. I think our racism is still with us and needs to be stated directly rather than indirectly.

New G-1.04: I think the removal of the category of inactive members is a missiological mistake. Granted too few congregations reach out to inactive members but it is an important ministry that should be revived rather than abandoned.

New G-3.0107: “Presbyteries may apportion requested funds to sessions within their bounds.” Does this mean that presbyteries may require sessions to pay particular amounts to the presbytery? Since we have eliminated per capita apportionments, what does apportion mean in this context?"

Some comments on the latter are:

1.0202 Why exchange the word “Kingdom” for “new reality? Isn’t Kingdom more Biblical?

1.01 Why leave out the clause about the resurrection? The current FoG 1.0100 is a clear quote from Scripture. Why change it?"

Saturday, November 3, 2007

Breaking Bread and Living in the Vine

Blessed Be the God and Father of our Lord Jesus Christ, who has blessed us with every spiritual blessing in the heavenly places in Christ. Just as He chose us in Him before the foundation of the world, that we would be holy and blameless before Him. In love He predestined us to adoption as sons through Jesus Christ to Himself, according to the kind intentions of His will, to the praise of the glory of His grace which He freely bestowed on us in the Beloved." (Eph. 1:3-6) NAS

Marcie Brown, Toby Brown, Dave Moody, Brad Larson, Viola Larson, Chris Larimer

Part of this week I have enjoyed some wonderful fellowship with a few blogger friends involved in the New Wineskins. Breaking bread together (well for some breaking corn bread) reminded me of how all who belong to the Church universal, in the past, in the future, in heaven and in the present, have fellowship together under the Lordship of Jesus Christ.

It is Jesus Christ who draws the Church to Himself, providing His disciples with nourishment, through faith, by our union with Him.




Because, in many ways this week, has brought me into fellowship with both those in New Wineskins and others in the renewal groups, I am reminded of a poem I used as one of my first postings on this blog. I wrote the poem over twenty years ago but it is good for the present time

Dave Moody, Chris Larimer, Janet Ruth

The Sweetness of Gathering to the Vine


The sweetness of gathering to the wine
is claimed by children resting in a tree
whose root became the food within the vine.

These, childlike made, they bless the cup and dine
upon the fleshy food they cannot see,
and drink the holy bloody wine.

Like sibling children fighting in a line,
who later laugh when by the bell set free,
these happy ones are laughing in the vine.

And raging gods whose deeds their shape confine
have called for war, whose very end shall be
determined by the drinking of the wine.

Go death to death, the children life define;
now blood of saints and Christ's good blood agree
the holy life is living in the vine.

If nails be sharp pursuing flesh to pine,
and wooden burdens bend and bruise the knee,
feast on the broken flesh, drink up the wine;
hold fast the fellowship within the vine.


Thursday, November 1, 2007

Literature, Resurrection and Jesus Christ



Human pictures of paradise, God's heaven, the home of his people, are never satisfactory. As I wrote in my last post, fallen humanity's attempts at utopia generally turn into earthly hells. And this failure to grasp a pure vision of our home with God is as it should be.

Paul writing of God's Wisdom, hidden in past ages, explains how his contemporaries failed to understand the promise of God's Wisdom, Jesus Christ, and therefore crucified him. He goes on to paraphrase the Old Testament, linking Jesus with God's promises now revealed:

"Things which eye has not seen and ear has not heard, and which have not entered the heart of man, all that God has prepared for those who love him."(1 Cor. 2:9b)

Home with God is linked to the believer's relationship with Jesus Christ. He is the One we now know through the pages of Holy Scripture, opened to us by the Holy Spirit who is sent by the Father and the Son. Our joy is now in Christ Jesus who we are united to by faith. We know the Son, yet, only anticipate heaven.

I once read a nineteenth century story of a woman's supposed vision of heaven. Interestingly enough what I read was a vision of an idealized United States in the nineteenth century. In that particular heaven, on Sunday afternoons, great Reformation leaders such as Luther and Calvin came to a library and lectured.

Native Americans were still not quite Christianized so they lived apart and were sent heavenly missionaries. Young people wandered here and there embedding roses in the marble floors of mansions.

Even C.S. Lewis', description of the future with Aslan (Jesus), in his book, The Last Battle, seems less than satisfactory. But a great deal of what Lewis writes about our future with God, in his essay, "The Weight of Glory" is very satisfactory.

For instance looking at the verse "Well done, thou good and faithful servant," and equating it with Jesus' statement that no one can enter heaven except as a little child, Lewis writes how one of the beautiful traits of a good child, or a dog or horse, is their love of praise. He goes on to write:

"And that is enough to raise our thoughts to what may happen when the redeemed soul, beyond all hope and nearly beyond belief, learns at last that she has pleased Him whom she was created to please. There will be no room for vanity then. She will be free from the miserable illusion that it is her doing. With no taint of what we should now call self-approval she will most innocently rejoice in the thing that God has made her to be, and the moment which heals her old inferiority complex forever will also drown her pride deeper than Prospero's book. ... In the end that Face which is the delight or the terror of the universe must be turned upon each of us either with one expression or with the other, either conferring glory inexpressible or inflicting shame that can never be cured or disguised."

But in my last post, Literature, Damnation and the Final Death, I wrote of Walter Wangerin, Jr, and his book Mourning into Dancing. I quoted Wangerin's picture of what he called Death Absolute, or the fourth death, the final death. He then wrote of the resurrection for those who belong to Jesus. I will end with his picture of our death and resurrection. It is long but beautiful:

"But I shall not perish! I, like the prodigal, will rather be coming home again!

No, this is not a wishful denial of the reality nor some incompleteness of the third death. My body will die. Every single relationship in which I now experience life--every relationship!-- will break. I will at once lose my place in the created world and friends and family and breathing, my reason, my senses and all my strength, yea, and my self--until the darkness is complete, until I am, from earthly perspectives, a nothing in a nowhere. I will die.

But I will not perish!

I shall not be lost utterly. I carry to the grave this promise: that 'God so loved the world that he gave his only Son, that whosoever believes in him should not perish--' Perish: now what Greek word do you suppose is used there? Right, me apoletai, the familiar 'loss' in its extremity, apollumi. 'Should not perish' says the promise, 'but have eternal life.'

How can this be? If death is my impotence to maintain any sort of relationship, and if life is lived in relationship, how could I ever live again?

Because the God who created once is Creator still. Because God established a new sort of relationship by his Son--a new covenant in which God does it all, and we allow the doing. Its a one-sided relationship, wherein the impotent one, the monstrously incapacitated one, receives the benefit--as when a weak child falls, but the father holds her hand and lifts her up again. The lifting is pure gift. The new covenant is Grace.

This relationship can endure even when I am helpless. Especially then. This relationship endures though I am nothing in a nowhere--because I remain a something in the heart of God! This relationship endures in spite of the flat reality of the grave and my own dissolution, my crumbling into dust, because my side of the covenant is not fulfilled by my flesh and blood but by Christ's--who continues to live, yes, even while they bury me and the worms translate my subtle brains to soil.

'My sheep,' says Jesus, 'hear my voice, and I know them, and they shall never perish [me apolontai!] and no one shall snatch them out of my hand.'

I will die. All my resources will exhaust themselves. In myself and on my own, I will not be.

But the Shepherd remembers my name.

The Shepherd will whisper, 'Walter'--and though I have no ears to hear, yet the whispering Lord will give me hearing.

The Savior will cry across the divisions: Walter Wangerin, Junior!'-- and though I have no tongue at all, the calling will give me voice. The Word of God has always contained my own capacity to answer it.

Walter Wangerin, come forth!'

And straightway I will rise up, laughing and loving and leaping, alive: 'Here I am! For you have called me!'

Alive again, eternally."